GUI's will always be in debate. It's a trade off between functionality and visual appeal. This is a fine line and we all define where that line is differently. With the xbox having limited resources, performance must be paramount. XBMC is a very handy tool and has grown to be a very functional dashboard. I use mine daily for many different types of media as do many others. How we choose to get from "A" to "B" is really down to user choice/preference. There are many options for navigating our xbox's and no one particular method is better than another in most cases. Its down to whatever feels comfortable to the end user really. I think Ellipsis is a smashing piece of work and if there was less choice, would be top of the tree or there about's. As thing's stand, there is lot's of choice for the XBMC dashboard skin, so, for me, Ellipsis misses the boat for a top contender slot. I would recommend people check it out though as it may be exactly right for other users.