Jump to content

CoinOPS IGNITE vs MAMEoX128 Plus  

32 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Thinking about it, wouldn't that sort of thing be something that could be changed in a custom skin? I'm guessing from your skin project thread that you're maybe planning on adding the ability to select between multiple skins from within CoinOps. Or am I totally wrong about that? If there was the option to select between different skins then people could make all sorts of different layouts for CoinOps. Talented skinners anyway. And that would be yet another feature that MameoX128 Plus doesn't have.

  • Replies 35
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Yes if many guys works on news skin you must unmask the choose skin option for them :P

I think ...

Posted
People that vote HK put your name here :) and why please.......

Yes, do this. I'm curious. I didn't think anyone would vote for it.

Posted
:) I did (and you should be able to guess who even if they log into CoinOPS forums all the time...why read stuff to critise if they never use it ;) )and why dont they put there name and reason here... let it out into the public and share the love
Posted

Yes guys, post your critiques for everybody can understand them and work on it ...

Posted
:) I did (and you should be able to guess who even if they log into CoinOPS forums all the time...why read stuff to critise if they never use it ;) )and why dont they put there name and reason here... let it out into the public and share the love

I didn't post my reasoning because, quite frankly, you don't seem to take criticism very well. You obviously have your own vision of what you want CoinOPS to be and that's great, but having tried the latest version just yesterday I can say that it's just not the MAME for me. I will explain why if you want but a lot of it comes down to personal taste so it will likely make no difference to you.

 

First off I would say that the GUI just doesn't look good to me. 128Plus with the dark blue MAMEdOX skin looks far more polished in my opinion. The large screenshots CoinOPS uses just don't work for me at all, they look stretched and blurry to my eyes. Also the game names are missing version details. This is confusing when you have more than one version of a game such as the 2P and 4P sets of TMNT and the clone is listed as the main set and the parent is listed as 'TMNT Extra'. CoinOPS is obviously not designed for people with large and diverse ROM collections so that's a big minus for me.

 

The options seem a bit messy. The first thing I did is enable the advanced options as I like to have as much control as possible over my emulation experience, but I was disappointed. In 128Plus there are many more options and they are all categorized, neatly laid out, and it's fairly clear what each of them do. In CoinOPS you have fewer options but they are all lumped together in what seems like no particular order and some of them aren't even correctly or intuitively labeled (Linear filtering is marked as Anti-aliasing). And on top of that when I first changed a few options to make things the way I like them the whole thing just crashed on me. I also wanted to change the default folders to those that I have my 128Plus ROMs and screenshots stored in. In 128Plus you can set up all the paths via the GUI but in CoinOPS I had to go into the TDATA folder to do this.

 

A lot of the in game options also seem to be missing. For example, if I don't want Start+Select to exit back to the game list there seems to be no way to remap this as there is in 128Plus. I could go on and on about things that are missing and things that others have already mentioned elsewhere, but there's no point because you've stated many times that these things have been omitted intentionally to avoid what you call 'clutter'. Again CoinOPS is clearly not designed for users like me that like to tweak and customize.

 

I'm glad those who enjoy CoinOPS enjoy it and I'm not saying you should change anything but I'll carry on with 128Plus myself as I feel it's a much more faithful port of MAME and it simply looks better and works better for the things I want.

 

Good luck with the project.

Posted

Excelent, thanks for your answer :)

 

But if you are a collector like me, and if CoinOPS upgrade his Skin with Viedo, previews, infos, etc ... it is not the same ?

What is better for you in oX128 please ?

 

Bye

Posted

For some of the reason +T+ were speaking of, related to games informations and also because of the romset, i like having all revisions of a PCB, even if there's some known problems on those games :)

Posted

sure I fix the issues at source some like to fix stuff up themselves and tweak it the way they want.... this build is more dev friendly but I killed alot of dev features in the release build as games wont want them... but behind the scenes the dev features have increased many tyo help me out alot

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...